? | |
Aeon Mira 7 did not appear to have a heat sensor near the laser head | Thunder Nova and Odin Series utilize Heat Sensors to detect fires and shut down, alert the operator |
Thunder machines will stop the machine from firing if the tube door is opened under normal conditions. | |
The only interlock sensor we could find was for the Lid. Likely wired direct to DrProt on Ruida. You can run with the rear tube door open without even having to bypass interlocks.....just open the door. | Thunder Nova series utilizes multiple interlock switches on the main lid and single interlocks on the other doors that are not bolted shut from the inside. The Odin use double interlock sensors on the doors that allow access to the laser beam. More on the Thunder System here. |
Thunder Dual Air Assist with Easy Access Knobs |
~$40 dual driver for x and y
No S/N or Model available, private labeled as AEON but available without
the markings. If one driver channel fails, the entire unit needs to be
replaced. Looks very similar to this other Rebranded Driver | As compared to the Leadshine drivers Thunder uses for the closed-loop hybrid motors. |
Steppers can lose steps and without having a feedback loop, the driver will not know and just keep running. This can lead to a crash of the laser head and damage to the machine. | Thunder user Hybrid Steppers from Leadshine called their Ez Servo Series |
The mounting is in a decent location, no preferred. It is nice to see
that there are jack bolts to adjust the tension of the belt. Motor is
small so Z moves while running may run into some loss of position since
it is not closed loop. | Thunder does not use a jack bolt on the Nova series but instead it has slotted brackets for tension adjustment. The ODIN series does use a jack bolt setup. |
Note that there is not a wire on LPWM1 which is used to adjust power output to the Laser Tube Power Supply input signal, they decided to use L-AN1 which is older Analog signal. 256mb version | Thunder laser now offers a Ruida controller with 1gig of memory for larger file storage. |
No z move buttons, Only available through the menu. Want to manually move the z.. you have to get into the menu to do so. | Thunder uses a HMI with Z Control and a custom skin. |
Exhaust fan activated by button only. Not on job start. Cannot take advantage of Start and End Delay from Lightburn for the exhaust fan? | As compared the the neat relay bank and TL Timer in the Thunder |
Notice the exposed terminals and non insulated connectors | As compared to the factory crimped insulated connectors in Thunder machines |
Not very clean or tidy. Unlabeled wires. Main Power does not appear to have AC filters | As compared to Thunder's Filtered main power distribution (2 Power Filters on the AC lines) |
Likely replaced once in USA with a 120v Coil Contactor. Wiring is far from neat and tidy. | As compared to Thunder's
Contactor that only controls the laser power supply and chiller to
isolate noise, leakage, and draw from high energy components from the
rest of the machine. |
Notice there is no opto-isolation on I/O | Thunder optically isolates the I/O on the LPSU to prevent high voltage leakage back to the DSP | Ruida does
provide Opto Isolation for the 4 discrete inputs and 4 discrete
outputs, does not appear to have OPTO isolation built in for the 2 Laser
Tube outputs. |
Possible external chiller alarm port, cut and left behind. HV tube wire
passing right under 110v supply. While it doesn't hurt anything, it is a
detriment to quality and cleanliness. | Thunder Supplies and 5000\5200 Active Chiller with all Nova 24 and larger machines with an alarm interconnect cable that is factory installed and is wired to the Ruida Constroller |
Pin 9 on the TL timer provides the 5V for the Red Dot Pointer with a spare channel on Pin 10 |
Wifi has been shown to be a poor method of transferring the files from a computer to the Ruida Controller. The communication protocol used is UDP which limits error checking. File transfer errors are widely known. Since the machine has a WIFI module, does it need to have a FCC certification? https://www.fcc.gov/oet/ea/rfdevice. No information could be found on the wireless device or a statement of conformity on the machine. The statement may be present, but could not be located. | Thunder ships machines with Ethernet and USB cable connections only. Thunder does however have information on the knowlegebase about how to configure for WIFI or the Lightburn Bridge. |
10lbs of potatoes in a 5lb sack comes to mind. Heat soak, noise, vibration and cramped location to work on. Why the small square inlet to the large duct? | Air flow across hot fan and pump to the chiller. Tight area to work in. | Notice the Soft Start Cap which is common to 120v motors but is also another failure point |
Chiller in/out passing right over the HOT air pump, heated air is being
pulled into the heat exchange, likely impacting tube efficiency. I don't
see how a constant coolant temp could be maintained. | Diagram showing the cooling air flow |
Note Plastic Tube mounts | Thunder provides a robust set of machined Aluminum adjustable mounts |
Bullet style laser beam source. Functional yes, classy no. | Thunder uses a purpose built Red Dot Pointer with the ability to tune the dot. |
Tube Label and Specs on the tube installed in this Aeon Mira 7 | Notice No testing info or actual peak power data
recorded. Thunder Laser China tests every tube and rejects the ones that
do not output 10% over the tube's nominal stated power output. | It appears to be a rebranded Ten-High tube maybe. Ten-High seems to be the only
ones that have a few wraps of bell wire at the output coupler. Note the
Reci appears to be an option in higher wattage machines and appears to
have testing information. |
Thunder 80w Reci Tube from a Nova 35 Testing Information |
Thunder 130 SPT Tube Label Example showing QC pass and dimensions |
6" duct runs to a hollow panel on the z table then below the machine. All exhaust is pulled from a hollow housing around the z bed. The exhaust connection and tubing is an additional failure point. | Thunder exhausts from under the Z bed and includes easy pull out crumb trays on the Nova lineup |
Quite frustrating head design, two bolts, AF sensor have to be removed prior to getting to the lens. While
the Thunder Odin does have a lens tray design with thumb screws, its
autofocus sensor is built behind the head, allowing you to easily swap
lenses out without the use of tools or removing
accessories. Every time you remove the AF sensor assembly you run the
risk of not installing it in the exact position it was in. | Currently Thunder uses optical AF eyes that look across the bed. At the ISA show in Vegas we showed off the new AF head that is Co-axial and not offset from the engraving location. |
Lots of tools to swap that lens out. Time is money. | Compare to changing out the Lens on a Nova machine, quick knob, tool-less change. Loosen the Heigh Adjustment knob, release the air fitting, lower tube, swap in reverse. This article shows how easy it is to swap lens tubes. |
It may come preinstalled but is it calibrated? Looks like the 5mp low res version? Thunder only sells
the 8mp versions for better resolution, even for the Nova 24. | Thunder sells a complete kit that you can DIY install that is 8mp and now comes with a USB extender cable for longer distances. Custom designed mount is more robust than the stock mount and is a captive shell design meaning the clips cannot break on the cover which would allow the camera to fall out or come out of alignment.ThunderCAMs vs. LightBurn & Other USB Webcams |
Elongated jack bolt used for motor tension, can lead to deflection, bending etc | Thunder uses a much shorter jack bolt to limit deflection |
They pack the linear guides
in the cabinetry and inside the gantry (behind the belt) to help keep it
clean. This may sound like a good idea and extend the PM cycle, but it
also adds complexity to the maintenance as you have to disassemble parts
to be able to access them. And eventually you will have to maintain
them. | We use 12 sealed
self-lubricating U-groove roller bearings in 3 sets that ride on steel
rails that are pressed into the gantry. No maintenance or lubrication is
necessary. If the bearings happen to need replacing, you can do it
quickly and painlessly with no disassembly other than loosening the
eccentric cams to release the tension and removing a shoulder bolt. |
Check the yellow highlighted values, are they as shown? | Note that the values may not be exactly the same, LB allows for multipliers to be set in order to get the time estimates right. Your engrave accel should be higher than 30000 if 5G acceleration is claimed. You can pull it up in the machine settings to verify as well. |